Required Elements: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Cowboy Altitude for Wyoming Fans!

Thoughts on Weir's Worlds Withdrawal

As you've read, three-time United States national figure skating champion Johnny Weir has withdrawn from the upcoming world championships in Torino, Italy.  Here are some of my thoughts.

The "duh" factor

Weir has been on television or in every other type of media every time you turn around.  He's been interviewed by dozens of outlets, he's been photographed at numerous parties.  Normally when skaters do this much media post-Olympics, they are not planning to skate at the world championships (in part because there has been no time to train).  So, it was no surprise when Weir dropped out.

The uncool factor

I don't like that Weir stated in an earlier post-Olympics press conference that he was definitely going to worlds, and that it would be a statement to the world and the judges.  And he added some unnecessary shots at other athletes:

Weir ended his comments with a vow: he won't play coy about his attentions. If he intends to compete next season, he will say so definitively, and soon.

"I'm not going to pull a Sasha Cohen or Michelle Kwan and say, 'I'm coming back, I'm coming back, I'm coming back' and then not do it," he said. "I mean, thank God, Sasha finally did come back. But I'm not going to do that to people. I think it's rude, especially to my fans. If I'm going to skate, I'll tell them I'll skate."

Now, I was happy Weir said this at the time, because I don't like to be teased.  But Weir has now turned himself into a liar by backing out of worlds when he explicitly stated he would be there, which is way worse than being a tease.  Not cool.  I understand why he's withdrawn and I assume it's the best decision (no one should go to a world championship when they are unprepared or they don't want to be there), but maybe this is why skaters should not speak about others and only worry about themselves - everything you say comes back to bite you!

The understandable factor

Johnny Weir stated the following in his withdrawal announcement (via Entertainment Weekly):

"And while I am still embracing my Olympic memories and have the momentum to move forward, I have decided that it is not advantageous at this time for me to partake in the World Championships in Torino, Italy. After my sixth place finish in Vancouver, I believe that I must take time to reassess my strategies and goals. While I understand the importance of competition, I feel that a short break at this time would be personally beneficial to me. I know all may not share my stance, but I can assure everyone that I will be re-energized after I’ve had time to rework my technique. I want to be a better competitor and win medals for my country and I hope everyone can respect my decision to take this time off.

I would agree it's not advantageous for Weir to skate at worlds, as much as I would love to see him there (I think he actually would have had a shot at a medal).  He skated his best performances of the year at the Olympics.  He has been basking in the media's obsession over his being robbed of a medal (disclosure:  I think Weir was underscored but I thought Takahashi deserved his bronze).  It is unlikely Weir would skate as well at worlds as he did at the Olympics, and he has nothing to gain at this point...it's much better to have seen him skate amazing and assume political forces kept him down (which may very well have been the case with Weir) then to see him go on a month later and (potentially) not skate as well.

The "Is this it?" factor

Weir successfully rode a wave of "my skating is for the people, not the judges" momentum into the Olympics.  This is a smart talking point that Weir has been pushing for awhile, as is evident to anyone who saw his mother say essentially the same thing in a recent episode of his reality series "Be Good Johnny Weir."  I think it's very possible that Weir may be done with ISU competition, although I'm sure he won't turn down a good old retirement press conference when he makes that decision for real.  UPDATED:  In the U.S. Figure Skating version of Weir's announcement, they don't mention that Weir said he wants to continue winning medals.  In the one above, he does mention that.  Still...I am unsure that we will see Weir competing next season, unless he suddenly becomes much less in media demand than he is now.

Weir has stated that he plans on continuing to skate in shows, and I hope he does.  He's such a beautiful skater that it will be sad if audiences don't get a chance to continue seeing him even if he quits competing.

So, I am kind of sad that we won't see Weir at worlds, but good luck to him on his other endeavors.  And it is a great opportunity for Adam Rippon, who is viewed as the future of U.S. men's skating.  Rippon recently won the Four Continents Championship, and hopefully he can follow that up with a successful senior worlds debut.

0 recs  |  Comment 1 comment |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

i agree that johnny had no right to call out specific skaters in his comments during that presser. i don’t fault him for backing out of the worlds because life can change from one minute to the next, causing people to re-arrange plans and priorities. in that vein, what right did he have to wag a finger at cohen and kwan? they were just doing what he just did as well – trying to figure out their lives, and sometimes one must re-think their strategies.

as for that whole “duty to the fans” thing, as a skating fan, i do not feel that any of the skaters “owe” me anything; i find it a privilege to watch them, but their career is first and foremost theirs alone. whether they choose to pull out of paid-for events like stars on ice is of course another issue, but as for competitions, it is up to the skaters and their health and well-being to make that decision, and the public has no right to judge.

by Susan Shin on Mar 10, 2010 1:33 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Required Elements is The Figure Skating Blog with the News You Need
Start posting on Required Elements »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Manhattan_bridge-1024-cutout_small
Yuna Drops Orser

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Most Commented

Skatergirl_small
The Worth of a Coach
Skatergirl_small
Kim Changes Training Venues

SBNation.com Recent Stories

NORTON MA - SEPTEMBER 03:  Zach Johnson tees off on the seventh hole during the first round of the Deutsche Bank Championship at TPC Boston on September 3 2010 in Norton Massachusetts.  (Photo by Michael Cohen/Getty Images) link

Deutsche Bank Championship: Jason Day, Zach Johnson Co-Leaders After Round One

Photo

Rangers Sign Mark Prior To Minor League Contract

BEREA, OH - MAY 01: Montario Hardesty #31 of the Cleveland Browns catches a pass during rookie mini camp at the Cleveland Browns Training and Administrative Complex on May 1, 2010 in Berea, Ohio.  (Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images) +1 updates

Browns' Montario Hardesty Reportedly Suffers Torn ACL, Will Miss 2010 Season

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Skatergirl_small LauraS